The word “meta” is all the rage lately since the Facebook name re-brand, but let’s get our crypto fundamentals in order before everything is referred to as metadata.
A Non-Fungible Token (NFT) is a token that represents a single specific digital asset, whether that be a .JPEG file, .GIF, .MP4, or whatever else. That file itself can’t be hosted on the Ethereum blockchain, so it’s hosted off-chain. NFT metadata specifies what that data is and includes things like the visual or auditory asset and other information like transactional history.
NFT metadata is essentially a workaround to avoid the technical and financial catastrophe (or, impossibility, rather) of hosting large files natively on-chain on Ethereum or other blockchain environments.
For example, if you wanted to run a full Ethereum node, you’d have to download the full Ethereum blockchain of about 1,050 GB (the archival nodes, or the entirety of the Ethereum blockchain since it launched, is about 9,000 GB).
That’s to run the entire Ethereum network– yes, all ETH-related matters, DeFi, NFTs, and dApps make up just under 1,100 GB.
In comparison, a 1080 full-feature length movie is about 2 to 4 GB on its own, and most high-quality images can be around 2 to 20 MB. There simply isn’t a way to store these files on the Ethereum blockchain because it would make running the network prohibitively storage and data-consuming.
How expensive are we talking? Gemini estimates that simply storing 1 GB of data on the Ethereum blockchain costs about 17,500 ETH (or $75.75 million as of November 2021). The costs to simply just store a blockbuster movie like James Cameron’s Avatar on the Ethereum blockchain would be more than the costs of making the $237 million film.
That’s where NFT metadata comes in. It’s a careful balance of utilizing the blockchain without burdening it with the data.
But, NFT metadata existing off-chain creates a few other issues, which we’ll get into below.
Let’s Get Technical: NFT Metadata
We’ll use the classic Ethereum ERC-721 token standard for the following NFT discussion.
Each ERC-721 contains a “metadata” string in its definition, which defines what the non-fungible token actually is. For example, this metadata could point to a specific .JPEG, which makes all the difference; although a CryptoPunk .JPEG and a DeadFellaz .JPEG are of comparable file size, they’re worth significantly different amounts.
The crux of the matter that trips people up about NFT metadata is where exactly files are stored off-chain– is it a Google Drive of some sorts? Is it some Amazon Web Services file storage? Who runs the show of hosting NFT metadata online?
Each NFT references the visual or auditory (image, audio, etc) file that exists online somewhere. It makes a request for the content at a specific location, which returns the content for you to see or hear. NFTs usually point to an IPFS (InterPlanetary File System) hash or an HTTP URL somewhere on the Internet.
The information is stored as a URI (Universal Resource Identifier) inside the Ethereum contract, rather than a JSON; storing a JSON would be prohibitively expensive and resource-demanding. The URI string, however, points to a location where the user can find the token’s JSON description.
The token’s metadata exists as a permanent, unalterable record on the blockchain, and this record describes what the token represents (its URI string to JSON), the token’s ownership and transaction history. The JSON file contains the image’s name, description, URL of where it’s hosted, and sometimes more granular information like the project’s total supply, type of encryption, and a unique signature.
Limitations of NFTs
This JSON metadata typically only identifies the asset, and doesn’t provide much in-depth information beyond the bare essentials.
The data isn’t very searchable or readable by other smart contracts, which is a kink and limitation of the Ethereum network that multiple projects are attempting to address.
The data is created by the token minters, who actually own the NFT contract. However, users can’t update the data, for better or for worse, which can be problematic for a few reasons.
For one, as we’ve seen in the evolving Internet ecosystem, links can break. Since the NFT metadata links you to somewhere else to view the art, if that link dies, you’ll essentially be pointing to a very expensive 404 error page. The JSON data can’t be updated by users, and neither can the links be fixed.
The crux of the issue is that if the data were able to be updated, the inherent value of the NFT could be compromised. For example, let’s say a malicious third-party found an exploit to change all the Bored Ape Yacht Club image metadata with pictures of real-world apes found on Google; the market would respond, and likely negatively.
Hosting Mechanisms also have their fair share of limitations:
- HTTP server owners could theoretically change the content of a specific server to whatever they like.
- IPFS is designed for decentralized hosting, but is still operated by centralized entities like NFT marketplaces that serve the role of IPFS nodes that keep the gateway live.
Final Thoughts: What is NFT Metadata Exactly?
As we’ve learned, NFT metadata is the second of the two key pieces to the NFT value proposition.
The first is that NFTs have a unique ID that distinguishes each token as unique from every other token. The ERC-721 tokenization standard utilizes Ethereum smart contracts to record transfers and changes of ownership of each particular NFT, which is a fairly computation-heavy endeavor. This is why gas fees are generally much higher for trading or minting NFTs compared to simply sending ETH on the network.
NFT metadata is baked into the second fundamental feature that makes NFTs tick. NFTs can link to data external to their smart contract, essentially allowing the network to reference data that exists off-chain. This keeps the computational costs of running NFTs on a network like Ethereum lower than they would be.
The Non-Fungible Token that defines the provenance of an asset lives on the blockchain, whereas the asset itself typically lives off-chain. There are few exceptions; for example, OnChain Monkeys is a collection created entirely on chain with a single transaction. There is no file storage solution needed since the entire collection is hosted on-chain.
There are quite a bit of misunderstandings around NFTs. Many people think NFTs are minted on the Ethereum blockchain through a platform like Rarible and — voila! — the art is non-fungible and lives forever in a decentralized manner on the blockchain. But that’s not entirely the case. NFTs, or “non-fungible tokens” are really only non-fungible to the extent that it refers to the actual token, not the underlying artwork or rare asset itself. As such, the token and the “asset” it represents are two completely different things.
Okay, let’s rewind a bit here. Although NFTs are often associated with digital art or GIFs these days, the reality is that they are better understood as a class of assets that are non-fungible. The $10 bill you used to pay for the coffee this morning? Fungible. The fingerprint you left on the bill when paying? Non-fungible. But is your fingerprint an asset? Debatable, depending on how much fingerprints go for on the black market these days (a joke, relax). But a key thing to remember is that non-fungible does not classify an object as rare, nor does it ensure that it is ‘rare’ or even decentralized.
This concept was probably best illustrated with a recent “rug pull” stunt conducted by one clever sculptor on the OpenSea platform. The artist exchanged the original JPEG images that the collectors thought they were purchasing with random pictures of rugs after the sale concluded. The intent of the stunt was to highlight the inherent problem of the current NFT infrastructure — which is mostly built on the Ethereum blockchain. By purchasing the NFT, the buyer would simply own the token to authenticate the JPEG listed on OpenSea, which at the time of purchase was a dope piece of art. But because the underlying digital asset itself is not decentralized, and might be stored on a central server somewhere such as on AWS or GCS, the buyer has no control in terms of what the NFT itself represents.
In other words, the non-fungibility is currently applied to the token representing the transaction of the purchase — not necessarily the owner of the physical (or digital) piece of art.
This is a common problem in the NFT sphere, as buyers often misunderstand the underlying infrastructure of the art they are buying, which can be problematic when there isn’t a physical equivalent of the purchase, ie: a digital GIF.
With most NFT marketplaces being built on Ethereum, another key problem is raised. The Ethereum network is often congested by other sectors such as DeFi, which eat up the majority of the bandwidth and exponentially raises the prices for minting and transacting NFTs. When compounded with the previously outlined problem, it is easy to see why the NFT art space is not the perfect picture it is painted to be after all.
This is where a platform like Pastel can paint a brighter future. Unlike Rarible or OpenSea, Pastel has built its own layer 1 blockchain to compete with Ethereum based platforms. This brings with it an innate advantage because the underlying architecture is designed to be perfectly outfitted and purpose-built for the sole use case for digital art and other rare digital assets, rather than being a do-it-all blockchain like Ethereum. With fewer projects demanding bandwidth, minting and trading NFTs on Pastel is significantly lighter on your (digital) wallet as well due to very low gas costs
In regards to the main problem of preventing “rug pulls”, Pastel ensures that the art (or other NFT) itself is uploaded, verified, and registered on the Pastel blockchain — rather than just the token it is minted with. Through a series of smart tickets living on the Pastel ledger, artists can store their masterpieces in a distributed fashion across a variety of Supernodes as opposed to just ensuring the token is non-fungible. This sophisticated storage layer, leveraging the RaptorQ fountain code algorithm, ensures that each asset is broken up and stored in a series of redundant, fungible chunks. These sets of chunks ar ethen distributed across the network using the Kademlia DHT algorithm. So what does this really mean? In short, even if over 90% of hosted instances suddenly go down, the remaining information can be reconstructed quickly and there is no possibility of the artwork disappearing.
So the next time you purchase an NFT, make sure you understand how and where your rare digital asset is stored — so that you won’t have the rug pulled out from underneath you.
Learn more about Pastel Network, and join us below!
Axie Infinity is a community-driven blockchain-based digital pet game that enables players to earn money while playing the game. Think of Axie as a hybrid between Pokemon, Tamagotchi, and CryptoKitties.
It is one of the most popular NFT token-based games, with over 19,000 monthly active on-chain users. One of the most notable characteristics of Axie Infinity and other NFT-based games is that users are able to bridge the in-game economy with real-world currency.
Over 25,000 ETH (over $45M) has been traded in the in-house marketplace, with the most expensive Axie being sold for 300 ETH ($540,000.)
About Axie Infinity:
Axie Infinity is a product of Sky Mavis, a game study based in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam.
The Sky Mavis and Axie Infinity team includes:
Trung Nguyen, Founder of Sky Mavis and Axie Infinity. He is a serial entrepreneur behind an E-commerce delivery startup called Loship.
Alexander L. Larsen is the Co-Founder of Sky Mavis and Axie Infinity game and is the current Chief Operating Officer of the venture. He is the business head behind the venture and handles the day-to-day operation of the company. He comes with a background in e-sport development and is a gamer, gaming competition organizer, and video journalist.
Viet Anh Ho is the Chief Technology Officer at Sky Mavis. He was previously a full-stack developer and an intern at both Google and Paypal.
- Tu Doan, art director and game director of Axie Infinity. He is a competitive Pokemon player and created the entire suite of Axie game characters. He also worked on Loship with Trung.
- Duy Trinh, Lead Animator Axie Infinity. He’s a graduate of a professional Hollywood Animation Studio and works as a freelancer.
- Quy Dau, Primary Software Engineer. He won the 2016 React Hackathon. He started his first company at the age of 21.
- Nam Nguyen, Chief Graphic Artist and Designer.
Launched in 2018, Axie Infinity has quickly grown alongside the rising popularity of NFTs and blockchain-based gaming.
The Cast of Axie Characters:
Axie Infinity is a decentralized game ecosystem built on the Ethereum blockchain, featuring a cast of digital characters. Per the game’s narrative, Axies are creatures that “love to battle, build, and hunt for treasure.”
Dubbed a “digital nation,” Axie Infinity presents a landscape in which users can collect, battle, or breed their characters.
Users can also build a collection of Axies and use them in a wide variety of games within the Axie Infinity world, called the “Terrarium.”
Axies gain experience points and level up by completing daily activities or through battle with other Axies. They come with specific traits that help determine battle outcomes; some characteristics make them more competitive than others.
There are over 500 body parts that can be acquired and traded, and each body part enables Axies to perform specific battle moves or receive an overall combat advantage.
There are four stats that determine a battle outcome: Health (HP), Skill, Speed, and Morale.
- Health (HP): How much of a beating your Axie can withstand before it’s knocked down.
- Skill: A skill stat determines the amount of damage you do; you can do more damage if you use multiple cards on your opponent during battle.
- Speed: Speed is critical because it determines the attack order in a battle. The faster the Axie, the quicker the attack. Speed also comes in handy in defense; faster speeds mean your Axie has a greater chance of avoiding a critical or lethal strike.
- If two battling Axies have the same speed, attack order is determined by the following stat priority: High speed > Low HP > High Skill > High Morale > Low Fighter ID.
- Morale: The morale score of Axie decides whether an Axie gets to make a critical strike on an opposing Axie. It also determines when an Axies is losing whether the losing Axie gets to make a last stand.
The above stats are influenced by an Axies’ class and body parts.
Axie classes are reminiscent of Pokemon types– each class has certain advantages and disadvantages in combat. Think Rock, Paper, Scissors. There are six common classes in Axies and three secret classes.
Common Classes: Aquatic, Beast, Bird, Bug, Plant, Reptile.
- A “Mech” is a hybrid offspring of a purebred Beast with a purebred Bug Axie.
- A “Dawn” is a hybrid offspring of a purebred Plant with a purebred Bird.
- A “Dusk” which is a hybrid offspring of a purebred Reptile with a purebred Aquatic
Axie Advantage and Disadvantage Breakdown:
Each class has an advantage over two other classes. Similarly, it has a disadvantage against two classes.
- Advantage: Bugs and Beast Axies.
- Disadvantage: Plant and the Reptile Axies.
- Advantage: Plant and Reptile Axies
- Disadvantage: Aquatic and the Bird Axies.
- Advantage: Bug and Beast Axies
- Disadvantage: Plant and the Reptile Axies.
- Advantage: Plant and Reptile Axies
- Disadvantage: Aquatic and the Bird Axies.
- Advantage: Aquatic and the Bird Axies
- Disadvantage: Beast and the Bug Axies.
- Advantage: Aquatic and Bird Axies
- Disadvantage: Beast and Bug Axies.
Axie Body Parts:
Each Axie has six body parts: horns, back, tail, eyes, ears, and mouth. Each body part has the ability to play a role during battle. Each ability is represented by a card. Only horns, mouths, backs, and tails determine what kinds of cards an Axie can use in battle.
A body part’s “class” also improves the four stats listed above: Health, Skill, Speed, and Morale.
Axies have around 500 different body parts options, each of which look different and provide relatively unique advantages.
The Battle is the Game Plan:
There are two ways an Axie can battle: PvE (E stands for environment) in an adventure or in 3v3 (3-on-3) battle against other Axies in an arena.
The goal for each sort of battle is to learn experience (EXP.)
PvE adventures: For example, one PvE battle takes place in the Lunacia Ruins in the Axie Terrarium. During the PvE, an Axie will face 36 levels of monsters. Successfully navigating each level gives the Axie some experience, allowing it to perform better in the next. The Axie will have to defeat three waves of monsters (on average) in each level to advance to the next stage.
Axies can earn anywhere between 50 EXP points to over 1200 EXP points per level. The EXP varies per level and doesn’t necessarily increase or decrease: for example, Level 30 pays 1209 in EXP points, and Level 36 pays 820 points to clear.
Here is a breakdown of how many EXP points are gained for winning each level:
3v3 (3-on-3) Battles: two teams of 3 Axies each face each other in a 3×3 battlefield.
The battle strategy generally determines the victor. An excellent plan considers the specific suitable Axies in each team, placement on the battlefield, what moves are utilized, and the order of those moves.
The Axie with the fastest speed gets to attack first, followed by the opposing side. Each team then takes turns until all three members of one team are defeated.
The victorious party’s members each earn 60 EXPs and the defeated get 20 EXPs each. If all three opposing Axies have been defeated, their rewarded EXPs go to the winning team.
Axie Infinity & the Blockchain: How Does Axie Infinity Work?
Axie Infinity leverages the blockchain to reward and incentivize players for engagement, as well as to provide access to a secondary market in which users can sell their Axies and other in-game objects. Axis and their body parts NFTs, specifically ERC9721 tokens. The Small Love Potion (SLP) is an item used to feed Axies is an ERC-20 token.
A token introduced at the end of 2020, the Axie Infinity Shard (AXS) is an ERC-20 token that acts as both a governance token, as well as an in-game currency that can be bought, traded, or earned by playing the game.
One of the most significant driving forces of Axie Infinity’s growth is its community, as dozens of reviews attest.
The community is mostly on Discord, which serves as a chat interface uniting the thousands of monthly users. As one of the most popular blockchain-based games to date, Axie Infinity has earned a first-mover advantage and dozens of long-time users. If you’re interested in playing Axie Infinity or researching it further, check it out at https://axieinfinity.com/.
MetaMask was built and launched in 2016 by ConsenSys, a largely Ethereum-focused blockchain development studio as a means to interact with Ethereum blockchain.
The wallet itself is non-custodial, meaning that the owner (you) doesn’t have to relinquish possession of their private keys to a third party. However, this comes with great responsibility, as we’ll get into below.
Launched as a software cryptocurrency wallet, MetaMask makes it possible for users to store and manage their private and public keys, broadcast transactions to the network, send and receive Ethereum and Ethereum-based tokens, connect to decentralized exchanges, and buy and sell NFTs.
MetaMask also aggregates multiple decentralized exchanges in a feature called MetaMask Swaps, where users can access the best exchange rate for ETH-based tokens at a service fee of 0.875% of the transaction amount.
As of August 2021, the MetaMask browser extension has roughly 10.5 million monthly active users, many of which are using the wallet to interact with the burgeoning DeFi and NFT ecosystems.
So, how do you get started with MetaMask?
It’s simpler than you might think, let’s get started.
Step 1: Understand
Before blasting off Ethereum to different addresses, it’s important to understand MetaMask is a non-custodial wallet.
This means that keeping your wallet account password, private keys, and Secret Recovery Phrase safe is your responsibility. The probability of human error with these sorts of wallets is fairly high, so go into your non-custodial wallet adventures understanding that it’s likely that you may be the most probable point-of-failure, and do everything in your power to prevent that.
Metamask provides a Secret Recovery Phrase of twelve words when you first make a wallet. Write this down and store it in a secure place offline–definitely not a Google Doc named “MetaMask Secret Recovery Phrase” or “Crypto passwords.” Don’t share this phrase with anyone. If you lose your phrase, you won’t be able to access your wallet and your cryptocurrency and tokens will be unrecoverable.
MetaMask is also a software application, meaning it’s almost always connected to the Internet and comes with the ever-so-slight vulnerabilities that a hardware wallet like a Ledger Nano S typically doesn’t.
Most people use something like MetaMask to utilize a small(er) percentage of their total cryptocurrency holdings to interact with the various dApps in the Ethereum ecosystem, not as a primary holding account.
Step 2: Download
Your browser will ask you to add the extension– allow it.
MetaMask also has an iOS and Android app.
Step 3: Create Your Account
Next comes the typical account sign-up stuff– create your password and write down your recovery seed phrase. (see Step 1).
Step 4: Make Sure You Wrote Your Seed Phrases Correctly
Don’t let one typo or misplaced word be the reason you can’t recover your account!
Step 5: Send ETH to address
Click on the “Buy” option to pull up a few options to deposit ETH into the wallet. Scroll all the way down, and you’ll see the “Directly Deposit Ether” option, which will give you your wallet’s public key.
Copy and paste your public key to the platform you plan on sending ETH from, select the amount of Ethereum to send, and click send. You’ll be able to monitor the transaction in EtherScan.
Step 8: Connect MetaMask to the dApp or Platform
Now, your MetaMask is ready to rock and roll– just find the dApp or site you want to interact with. Let’s say we want to connect our MetaMask to our OpenSea to buy our first NFT.
On the account section in OpenSea, you’ll see a “Connect your wallet” section with a list of wallets that includes MetaMask.
Click MetaMask, which will pull up a request from the MetaMask browser extension that asks you whether you want to connect with the site.
Step 9: Sign the Signature
If you’re 100% certain you’re on a legitimate site and not some knock-off spam site (let’s say there is an “OponSee.io” or “0penSea.io” scammy clone replicate, which would likely be a malicious attempt to get you to sign over your MetaMask access.)
As you interact with the OpenSea ecosystem, you will be presented with multiple requests to sign a transaction with your MetaMask account.
Suppose we want to buy an NFT from The Heart Project. We find one we like, click “buy”, and view the subtotal. Upon clicking “confirm checkout”, our MetaMask extension would open up with the estimated gas fee for the transaction and price of the NFT.
We now have one final chance to reject or confirm the transaction.
Let’s say gas fees and transaction price looks good to us and we want to buy the NFT. We click confirm, and the transaction should go through, leading you to a “your purchase is processing” page, which shows the transaction hash number that can be traced to Etherscan.
Once the transaction finishes processing, your NFT will appear in your OpenSea profile. The NFT token itself, however, is held in your MetaMask wallet.
Final Thoughts: Welcome to MetaMask
So, there you have it– how to use MetaMask from scratch and buy your first NFT on OpenSea.
For now, MetaMask is one of the leading NFT wallets, and familiarizing yourself with it will make your NFT exploration process much more straightforward.
Since all ERC-20 and ETH-based tokens are compatible with MetaMask, you can utilize the wallet for a wide variety of Ethereum storage and interaction related purposes. Note that if you’re looking to interact with another blockchain ecosystem, such as the Solana ecosystem, MetaMask won’t work; you’ll need a different wallet (for example, Plasma for Solana.)
The Bored Ape Yacht Club (BAYC) is an Ethereum-based NFT collection of 10,000 unique Bored Apes. Each Bored Ape has a basket of traits programmatically generated from over 170 traits, including expression, clothing, headware, and more.
Each Bored Ape doubles as a Yacht Club membership card, which grants the holder access to members-only benefits. The first released benefit is a collaborative graffiti board called THE BATHROOM, a digital board likened to a dive bar bathroom wall.
BAYC holders get access to the BAYC Discord, a server where owners chat and hang out.
Perhaps the most notable advantage of the BAYC is access to additional NFT collectibles such as Bored Ape Kennel Club dogs, which are usually airdropped for free to wallets holding a BAYC NFT. These new NFTs are often resold for decent chunks of change.
Future benefits plan to be unlocked as the project progresses along with its roadmap.
Ape holders also have full commercial usage rights over their NFT.
Bored Apes became incredibly popular in the throes of an early-2021 NFT profile picture wave, and they have become particularly popular among NFT-savvy celebrities.
About Bored Ape Yacht Club
The Bored Apes are ERC-721 tokens on the Ethereum blockchain, and are hosted on IPFS.
When the project launched in April 2021, an ape could be purchased for just 0.08 ETH. Thirty apes were withheld from the initial sale, and were earmarked to be used for giveaways, puzzle rewards, and the four creators.
Today, Bored Apes regularly sell for six to seven figures; a collection of 101 Bored Ape Yacht Club NFTs recently sold for a whopping $24.4 million at a Sotheby’s auction in September 2021.
What an historic moment for the club: the @Sothebys auction of 101 Bored Apes has closed at over $24m. Congratulations and THANK YOU to the whole ape community. To the buyer, I think we speak for everybody when we say: WELCOME TO THE CLUB. ☠️🦍⛵️ pic.twitter.com/NKxHekC0ny
— Bored Ape Yacht Club (@BoredApeYC) September 9, 2021
BAYC has generated upwards of $1 billion of trading volume for the original BAYC and its variant sets, like Mutant Ape Yacht Club and Bored Ape Kennel Club.
The BAYC project was created by Yuga Labs, a group of four friends under pseudonyms:
- GORDON GONER.
- EMPEROR TOMATO KETCHUP.
- NO SASS.
The official BAYC site can be found here.
Bored Ape Yacht Club Collaborations and Airdrops
The BAYC has seen two airdrops:
- Free Bored Ape Kennel Club dog NFTs
- A “mutant serum” NFT that generated a Mutant Ape Yacht Club NFT.
In August 2021, Bored Ape holders were given a “mutant serum” which allowed them to mint a free Mutant Ape in the likeness of their original form.
— AlexisOhanian 7️⃣7️⃣6️⃣ (@alexisohanian) August 29, 2021
Yuga Apes also listed 10,000 new Mutant Apes for sale that anyone could buy for 3 ETH, all of which sold out in under an hour, generating $96 million for the project.
Notable Bored Ape Yacht Club Holders
One of the first athlete celebrities to buy a Bored Ape Yacht Club NFT and use it as a social media avatar was three-time NBA champion Steph Curry, who purchased an Ape for $180,000 in Ethereum in August 2021.
The list of BAYC athlete celebrities includes the NBA’s Josh Hart and Tyrese Haliburton, the NFL’s Dez Bryant and Von Miller, and artists like The Chainsmokers, Waka Flocka Flame, and Jermaine Dupri.
Plenty of corporations and publications have aped into the BAYC, including Arizona Iced Tea.
Final Thoughts: What’s Next for the Bored Ape Yacht Club
Among future NFT drops (unannounced), the BAYC plans to launch an ERC-20 token in Q1 2022. The mechanics and functionality of the token are currently being smoothed over, but some speculate it could work as a DAO governance token, or perhaps something to help the project expand into DeFi.
Good evening, apes. Been hearing a question around the club a lot:
WEN TOKEN? 🤔
Wen token indeed . . . Some thoughts below.
— Bored Ape Yacht Club (@BoredApeYC) October 8, 2021
The BAYC is regarded as the most valuable NFT project launched in 2021 in terms of its community and market volume, and it’s nestled into the rankings just behind Larva Labs’ CryptoPunks.
Perhaps the most notable metric for the BAYC success is its secondary market activity– the project has taken on a life of its own due to an active, and now increasingly more affluent, the base of users. The most popular BAYC secondary market is on OpenSea.
As BAYC helps lead the charge for NFTs as profile pictures, NFT fans would be keen to observe how certain projects develop into status symbols– and how quickly a project can transition from a quiet launch of .08 ETH to selling for millions in just months.